Building Relationships and Providing Unmatched Customer Service Request a QuoteUpdate Your Contact Information


  • Individuals looking for a local independent agent to manage all of their personal insurance needs…auto, home, life and health
  • Large and small business owners in search of quality business insurance programs that provide the coverage they need at a very competitive price
  • Human Resource Managers looking for assistance in managing their employee benefits programs
  • Member Benefits Service Directors seeking custom insurance services for regional and national associations


We are very pleased with Hibbs Insurance Agency. The staff is courteous and professional. We are very satisfied with our insurance coverage. Hibbs personnel goes above and beyond in providing expert service.

– Billy A., customer since 2011

There is always someone friendly and available to provide immediate service when I call. If I need “Proof of Insurance”, all I have to do is make the call. You periodically check my policies and coverage to see if you can reduce my cost. You don’t get any of this from an internet insurance provider. Steve

– Stephen S., customer since 2011

We have been with Hibbs Ins for many years. Mike and staff have always given us excellent service. They have been there for us with anything we need. We trust Hibbs Ins to search for the best insurance at the best rate to fit our needs. Thank you Mike and staff.

– Customer since 2011

I have been with Hibbs Insurance for about 15 years and the agents have always looked out for my best interest. They have continued to look for the best deals for my needs. They are also super at keeping up with the status of my documents making sure that I have submitted the correct paperwork on time which is so helpful with my busy life. It is so nice to know they have my back!

– Amy B., customer since 2015

We moved to Paducah about 10 years ago. Everyone we talked to had only the highest opinion of Hibbs Insurance. My husband was very pleased with the auto insurance rated and we both we so pleased to find an outstanding agency so close to our home.

– Customer since 2012

Offering Insurance from these outstanding companies:

safeco insurance
ohio casualty insurance
liberty mutual insurance
state auto insurance companies
the hartford
aaa insurance
foremost insurance group
Anthem BlueCross BlueShield
American Collectors Insurance
Mapfre Insurance
American Modern
American Reliable Insurance Company
Erie Insurance